In the popular science- fiction film, Rise of the Machines, against all odds, humans prevail over their artificial intelligence robot counterparts. In a “life imitates art” moment, the stagnation of robo-advisors in recent years in the retirement industry may be signaling that pure automation simply has its limitations.
While robo-advisors like WiseBanyon, Wealthfront and Betterment are now offering cash incentives for new clients and referrals (a sure sign of sluggish adoption rates), many of the major brokerages and record keepers are now offering some type of automated account management technology. At the same time, robo-advisors (perhaps seeing the writing on the wall) have begun to offer live, human advisors to supplement the robo-advice.
This is a similar pattern we have seen in many other industries where the promise of pure automation has been eroded by incumbents meeting the “pure-play” automation process with technology of their own, diminishing the appeal of the technology-only providers. Or take the example of hard-wired GPS and navigation systems in automobiles; why pay thousands of dollars for that extra technology when almost any new smart phone can do the same exact thing, for free?
It certainly appears that the robo-providers and the traditional advisory channels (human-based) are adopting the benefits of the other’s strengths; the likely outcome will eventually be some type of hybrid approach. The question is, can the robo-advisors stay around long enough and gain enough market-share to survive before the traditional brokerages and record keepers close the technology gaps and make technology pure-play robo’s irrelevant?
Using history as a guide, it does not bode well for the pure-play robo-advisors. Again, a likely scenario played-out in other industries may see the top robo’s being acquired by the larger brokerages and providers.
This is not to diminish the appeal, the innovation or the benefits of robo-advisors; it is just a very well-defined marketing evolution that has been played-out in other industries. Robo-0advisory technology is here to stay, the real question will be, who will be providing it?
Mr. Kelly is an expert in online marketing, search engine optimization, content development and content distribution. He has consulted some of the top brokerages, media companies and financial exchanges on online marketing and content management including: The New York Board of Trade, Chicago Board Options Exchange, International Business Times, Briefing.com, Bloomberg and Bridge Information Systems and 401kTV.
He continues to be a regular market analyst and writer for ForexTV.com. He holds a Series 3 and Series 34 CFTC registration and formerly was a Commodities Trading Advisor (CTA). Tim is also an expert and specialist in Ichimoku technical analysis. He was also a licensed Property & Casualty; Life, Accident & Health Insurance Producer in New York State.
In addition to writing about the financial markets, Mr. Kelly writes extensively about online marketing and content marketing.
Mr. Kelly attended Boston College where he studied English Literature and Economics, and also attended the University of Siena, Italy where he studied studio art.
Mr. Kelly has been a decades-long community volunteer in his hometown of Long Island where he established the community assistance foundation, Kelly's Heroes. He has also been a coach of Youth Lacrosse for over 10 years. Prior to volunteering in youth sports, Mr. Kelly was involved in the Inner City Scholarship program administered by the Archdiocese of New York.
Before creating ForexTV, Mr, Kelly was Sr. VP Global Marketing for Bridge Information Systems, the world’s second largest financial market data vendor. Prior to Bridge, Mr. Kelly was a team leader of Media at Bloomberg Financial Markets, where he created Bloomberg Personal Magazine with an initial circulation of over 7 million copies monthly.
Latest posts by Timothy Kelly (see all)
- 6 Pillars of 401k Prudence Every Sponsor Should Follow - June 21, 2017
- 401k Investment Automation on the Rise - June 19, 2017
- FOMC- FED Chair Janet Yellen Live Video Press Conference June 14, 2017 (2:30 PM) - June 14, 2017